Ep 33: Back to Whatever Normal Is

Aug 21, 2019 | The Nonprofit Experience - A Podcast

Through the lens of the devastating floods across Nashville and Middle Tennessee in May of 2010, Lori Shinton of Hands on Nashvile and Regine Webster from the Center for Disaster Philanthropy talk about disaster response and the challenges organizations and communities face in the aftermath.

Listen from Soundcloud at the bottom of the page

Season 3, Episode 1

The Relationship:

Regine Webster (left) and Lori Shinton (right)

Lori Shinton is the president and CEO of Hands on Nashville, a volunteer resource center connecting volunteers to more than 150 partner organizations across Nashville. Usually that means Lori is directing volunteer efforts to address homelessness or gentrification. Other times, as with the 2010 floods across Tennessee, Hands on Nashville battles natural disasters too.

Regine Webster serves as chair-elect for Hands on Nashville and is also vice president and founding executive director of the Center for Disaster Philanthropy which focuses on maximizing donor impact in response to disasters across the globe. Based in Nashville, the 2010 floods brought her home and her work together.

The Conversation:

Through the lens of the devastating floods across Nashville and Middle Tennessee in May of 2010, Lori and Regine talk about disaster response and the challenges organizations and communities face in the aftermath.

For organizations that respond to disasters, the outpouring of support following destructive events can actually bring those organizations out of financial hardship, but one of the biggest pitfalls is not having a natural way to scale back to pre-disaster operations.

Volunteers during the Nashville floodingLori and Regine also discuss how interest, volunteer time, and money often evaporate once the disasters leave the headlines, even though much of the work to be done may come months and years later. 

For organizations responding to disasters and community needs, in-kind donations are often referred to as “the second disaster.” Nonprofit work slows down when organizations don’t have the time, space, or staffing capacity to sort through and deal with potentially unnecessary or ill-timed in-kind donations. When it comes to donations, cash is king and this is borne out in the data showing how every dollar can be turned into clean water, shelter, and more.

The two also talk about disaster fatigue and the numbing effect of increasing disasters and the nonstop news cycle.

Topic Timestamps

Prologue and introduction

  • 00:00 – Prologue
  • 00:18 – Introduction to Lori Shinton and Regine Webster
  • 01:29 – Lori Shinton and Regine Webster talk about their experiences of the 2010 flooding in Tennessee

“Let’s talk about disaster a little bit”

  • Image of the flooding in Nashville from above04:01 – Lori talks about how disaster events have lifted HON out of financial hardship
  • 05:00 – Organizations like HON are called to do more during disasters, but it can be difficult to shrink back down to pre-disaster operations
  • 07:03 – Lori gives some stats from HON volunteering between May and December 2010
  • 07:41 – Regine talks about successful recovery and the two talk about difficulties in getting people to give support and volunteer after the disasters have left the headlines

“How do we honor the gift and what can we do with it?”: In-kind donations

  • 11:13 – Ill-timed or unneeded in-kind donations can be the “second disaster” for organizations responding to community needs and how “cash is king”
  • 14:53 – The Center for International Disaster Information provides advice about in-kind donations and they articulates how cash is the best donation (see below for video on cash donations)

“An ounce of prevention”: Patterns of giving and the monetary value of readiness

  • 15:41 – Most disaster giving happens within the first 60 days as “relief” and only 3% of individual donors give repeat disaster gifts
  • 17:19 – The highest motivations for giving are the magnitude and a connection to the place. Disasters are on the rise, but it is hard to tell the story of readiness and preparation
  • 18:50 – Even beyond disasters, prevention efforts are unfunded and harder
  • 19:29 – An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure: often fiscally at a $1 to $7 ratio up to a $1 to $18 ratio. A similar ratio exists in the return on investment in volunteerism

Disaster fatigue and the “numb factor”

  • 20:29 – Disaster fatigue in individual and foundational giving
  • 22:17 – Do our language choices effect the numb factor?: “There’s only so many times we can hear ‘This is the largest storm to ever make history'”
  • 23:10 – With the constant attention-grabbing news cycle, it can be hard to figure out what to respond to
  • 23:55 – Lori notes that when people are directly impacted there is an immediate response, but muses that it dissipates quickly

Wrap up

  • 24:58 – Lori and Regine close up the conversation
  • 25:27 – Outro: Plant a tree, support your local library, and give us a five-star review on Apple Podcasts


Center for International Disaster Information video on cash donations:

Ways to listen to The Nonprofit Experience:

Like what you hear? Leave us a review on Apple Podcasts! It makes a big difference.


Images of 2010 Tennessee flooding courtesy of Hands On Nashville

Related Posts

Ep 35: Trust in the Age of Disbelieving

What do a science foundation and an art museum have in common? This week, we pair Adam Falk, president of the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation, with Adam Weinberg, the Alice Pratt Brown Director of the Whitney Museum of American Art. Last year, the Sloan Foundation granted $100,000 to the Whitney for a exhibition exploring the intersection of art and science over the last 50 years. In this episode, the two Adams talk about the importance of partnerships like this one, how to increase trust in both art and science, and how the public interacts with it.

Ep 1: Check Your Bias

Communication professionals Melanie Davis-Jones and Katie Todd talk about affecting systemic change, and challenging our own thinking about the assumptions that we make.

The When, Where, and How of Informed Disaster Relief

The Center for Disaster Philanthropy transforms disaster giving by providing timely and thoughtful strategies to increase donors’ impact during domestic and international disasters. With an emphasis on recovery and disaster risk reduction, they aim to raise awareness of the life cycle of disasters and create plans for informed giving and relief.